User:MGorny/Proxy-Maint vs Sunrise
From Gentoo Wiki
Jump to:navigation
Jump to:search
Here's a draft table comparing own repository, Sunrise and proxy-maint.
| Own repository | Sunrise (discontinued) | Proxy-maint | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Audience | users who explicitly add your repository | users who explicitly add Sunrise repository | all Gentoo users |
| Commit mode | direct commit access | direct commit after IRC review to the development repo, then Gentoo dev merges it to the public repo | Gentoo dev merges your changes (pull request or patch workflow) |
| Maintainer status | up to the owner | no explicit maintainers | possible explicit maintainer status |
| Packages accepted | any packages | only packages not in ::gentoo, reasonably working/maintained | new or existing packages, reasonably working/maintained |
| Stable packages? | up to the owner | only ~arch accepted | maintainer can request stabilization |
| Gentoo-provided QA | most basic failure checks via the CI service, other up to the owner | review by the Sunrise project team | full review by proxy-maint team and/or other devs + pkgcheck-based CI |